Hebdo & Freedom of Expression

The previous issue of the French satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo
A 2014 issue of the French satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo

charlie-hebdo-logo

Charlie Hebdo, Freedom of Expression v Fears of Extremism

Atheism UK unequivocally condemns the killings of journalists and cartoonists at the Paris based magazine Charlie Hebdo on 7th January 2015. This was, primarily, a religiously motivated attack to avenge insults to the prophet Muhammad through his depiction in cartoons.

To stay within the law, publishers must decide when speech or expressions ridicules, offends, insults, abuses – or is hateful (1). The Charlie Hebdo satirists created images which had the potential to profoundly offend people of different faiths – they knew their work could also trigger violent breaches of the peace. But, had they drawn their cartoons in the UK (2), would they have been prosecuted under The Racial and Religious Hatred Act 2006 (3) – which says that threatening (but not insulting or abusive) behaviour is unlawful?   In law, the Act, which applies to England and Wales, states that “a person who uses threatening words or behaviour, or displays any written material which is threatening, is guilty of an offence if he intends thereby to stir up religious hatred.” (3,4) If the French had the equivalent of the 2006 Act, would the gunning down of Charlie Hebdo have taken place? (5)

References

(1) Hate speech laws in the United Kingdom, Wikipedia, accessed 31st January 2015
(2) Williamson, David, Wales Online‘Would Charlie Hebdo have been published in the UK?’, accessed 31st January 2015
(3) Racial and Religious Hatred Act 2006, accessed 31st January 2015
(4) ‘The BBC, Charlie Hebdo and Jesus & Mo’, accessed 31st January 2015
(5) ‘Who is the zealot and the fanatic?’, accessed 31st January 2015

Note: To minimise the possibility of incitement of violence towards members of Atheism UK and to reduce the possibility of perceived hate expression towards Muslims by republishing provocative images, the Atheism UK main website (as agreed by the Atheism UK Council February 2015) does not contain images or links to images of Charlie Hebdo Mohammed cartoons.

charlie-hebdo-shooting-tribute-cartoons-cartoonists-2

Many of the links below are to articles that debate the limits to freedom of expression and which discuss our fears of violent extremism.

Charlie Hebdo Portal Pages

Charlie Hebdo links

About Atheism UK

Our sole objective is the advancement of atheism. From this, we derive our key principles, which in turn inform our policies and strategies. Atheism UK’s ultimate goal is the end of religious faith – the false and irrational belief that God exists – and of religion, the social manifestation of faith. We campaign, from an atheist perspective, against the false and pernicious claims of religion, its privileges and its malign practices. We reject the notion that faith and religion should not be questioned, and we seek to create an environment of atheistic thought.

One Reply to “Hebdo & Freedom of Expression”

Leave a Reply